Clubhead Design Technology “Firsts”
Created By Tom Wishon
Because the component clubmaking industry has never been able
to compete with the vast marketing programs of the large assembled
club companies, there is a tendency among golfers to believe that
all of the significant design achievements and breakthroughs in
golf equipment and clubmaking come only from the large brand name
golf companies.
In an effort to offer you more accurate information in your quest
for true game improvement, below is a complete overview of the
various clubmaking firsts that have come from the design and clubmaking
technology experience of Tom Wishon Golf Technology.
[Click a title below for more information. To view Tom's design
firsts since starting TWGT in 2002, please
click here.]
- First injection molded polymer and metal
ironhead
1989 - Dynacraft* IMI-703 (prototype model
only)
- First metal woods with power chamber
attached behind the face
1990 - Dynacraft Greyshadow Wood
- First vertical flow weighted iron set
1990 - Dynacraft Genesis Irons
- First set of irons to use different steel
alloys for different heads within the same set
1991 - Dynacraft Vari-Steel Irons
- First set of irons to combine hollow
and solid body construction within the same set
1991 - Dynacraft Innerdyn Irons
- First set of metal woods and irons with
a face insert
1992 - Dynacraft Coalition Woods and Irons
- First one-piece investment cast undercut
cavity ironhead
1994 - Golfsmith** RMC270 Irons
- First wooden driver head >250cc in
volume/size
1994 - Golfsmith Long Jon Laminated Maple + Graphite Insert
Driver
- First metal wood manufactured with no
internal foam filling
1994 - Golfsmith Solid Tone Stainless Steel Driver
- First set of ironheads with all CNC
machined faces
1995 - Golfsmith CNC5000 Irons
- First graphite driver with heel weighting
for slice correction
1995 - Golfsmith AccuCore Graphite Driver
- First graphite + metal hollow cavity
driver head
1995 - Golfsmith Power Link Driver
- First metal wood with adjustable hosel
sleeve for customizing the face angle and lie
1995 - Golfsmith AHT metal woods
- First driver family designed with specifications
matched to different golfer swing speeds
1995 - Golfsmith Designated Drivers
- First titanium metal wood introduced
in the USA
1994 - Golfsmith Titanium 230 Driver
- First putter head with polymer backed
face
1995 - Golfsmith Insulator Putter
- First iron set with progressive topline
thickness for vertical center of gravity change
1996 - Golfsmith XTR II Plus Irons
- First stainless steel driver head to
exceed 225cc volume
1996 - Golfsmith SS-235 Driver
- First heel weighted metal wood driver
for slice correction
1996 - Golfsmith AccuCore Driver
- First metal wood with titanium wrap-around
face construction
1997 - Golfsmith BlackHawk Driver
- First metal wood with stainless body
+ aluminum hosel
1997 - Golfsmith Bi-Metallic woods
- First metal woodhead to exceed 350cc
volume
1997 - Golfsmith Long Jon jumbo metal driver
- First metal wood with aluminum body
joined to stainless steel sole for ultra-low CG
1997 - Golfsmith Super Track Woods
- First titanium iron with bi-metal construction
introduced in the USA
1997 - Golfsmith MWD1000 Irons
- First clubheads designed with weight
addition cavity at the base of the hosel
All new Golfsmith, Penick clubhead models starting in 1997
- First iron with titanium face insert
+ high density metal weighting bar for 3-Metal construction
1998 - Golfsmith BlackHawk Irons
- First boron carbide metal matrix investment
cast clubhead
1998 - Golfsmith Cermet 2000 Driver
- First Driver with maraging steel alloy
face to exceed 300cc in volume
1998 - Golfsmith Super Sonic Boom Driver
- First beta grade titanium alloy driver
introduced in the USA
1998 - Golfsmith Beta Titanium 255LT Driver
- First iron manufactured with aluminum
alloy body
1998 - Golfsmith TG System Irons
- First iron with multiple face thickness
variations for CG and weight distribution control
1998 - Golfsmith Jetstream 2 Irons
- First set of metal woods matching stainless
steel fairway woods with a titanium driver
1999 - Snake Eyes CMF Metal Woods
- First Metal Wood to match face thickness
to different golfer specific swing speed ranges
1999 - Snake Eyes Elasteel driver and 3 wood
- First metal wood with wrap-around face
construction forged from high strength steel
2000 - Golfsmith TI Steel 465
- First iron and wood set with progressively
moving tungsten weighting for specific flight performance
2000 - Lynx Black Cat MTW Woods and Irons; Harvey Penick Plus
Irons; Golfsmith Sterling Irons
- First utility driving iron with heel
located tungsten weighting
2000 - Golfsmith XPC3 Driving Iron
- First USGA C.O.R. non-conforming driver
with steel alloy face construction
2000 - Snake Eyes AerMet CMF Drivers
- First Thin Face Forged Steel Set of
Irons
2001 - Snake Eyes Fire Forged Irons
- First Putter head with vertical CG positioned
at same height as the CG of the golf ball
2001 - Snake Eyes Straight In Putters
- First putter head with ultra-low friction,
ultra-thin face insert to reduce putt side spin
2002 - Golfsmith Friction Free Putter
2003 - Wishon Golf Smoooth Series Putters
To view Tom's design ‘firsts’ since starting TWGT
in 2002, please click here.
top of page
-
First injection molded polymer and metal ironhead
1989 - Dynacraft* IMI-703 (prototype
model only)
Described in US patent #5,333,871, this was the golf industry’s
first ironhead designed by injection molding a light and strong
polymer material over a heavy steel sole and inner core piece.
The intent was to create an ironhead with Center of Gravity
and weight distribution that could be varied a lot more significantly
than in any full homogenous metal or multi-metal construction.
top of page
-
First metal woods with power chamber attached behind
the face
1990 - Dynacraft Greyshadow Woods
This metal wood design incorporated a 5/8” diameter
x 5/8” diameter steel cup permanently attached in the
center of the face on the back side of the face of a 17-4
stainless steel investment cast set of metal woods. The purpose
of the cup, or chamber behind the face was to ‘capture
and concentrate’ energy from impact with the ball that
could be directly behind the point of center face impact.
While innovative in concept, and while the cup did contribute
to a solid feel of impact, this was not exactly one of Tom’s
designs that was founded in enough scientific fact to be considered
technically significant.
top of page
-
First vertical flow weighted iron set
1990 - Dynacraft Genesis Irons
Hundreds of sets of irons in the 1990s to present, many which
have been made by a number of the largest golf companies,
borrowed their weighting concept of progressing the placement
of mass low on the long irons to higher on the short irons.
The Genesis iron was the first in the golf industry to introduce
such a concept of keeping the CG low on the less lofted heads
to help increase launch angle, and the mass higher in the
back cavity as loft increased to prevent hitting the ball
too high with the high lofted irons in the set.
top of page
-
First set of irons to use different steel alloys
for different heads within the same set
1991 - Dynacraft Vari-Steel Irons
The Vari-Steel, short for variable steel alloys, was designed
using 17-4 stainless steel for the body material of the long
irons, 431 stainless for the middle irons and 1030 carbon
steel for the short irons in the matched set. While most certainly
a “pain” for the foundry to manufacture because
of the requirement to change steel alloys in the investment
casting process and monitor different heat treatment procedures
for each segment of the set, the Vari-Steel irons employed
the use of three different steel alloys in the same set to
offer golfers a difference in ‘feel’ and material
hardness through the set.
top of page
-
First set of irons to combine hollow and solid body
construction within the same set
1991 – Dynacraft Innerdyn Irons
Full sets of two-piece, investment cast hollow body irons
brought about greater perimeter weighting and movement of
the CG further back from the shaft – both proven features
for game improvement for middle to higher handicap players.
However, moving the CG further back from the shaft is not
necessary in the higher loft irons, where the loft is enough
to enable all levels of golfers to easily get the ball up.
The Innerdyn design consisted of hollow body, rear-CG long
irons with one-piece, solid body middle and short irons.
The Innerdyn recognized that a low and rear-located CG was
worthwhile in the longer, less lofted irons, but such a design
feature is wasted on the irons where the normal loft increase
and length decrease combine to make the iron easy-to-hit.
Thus the game improvement features of the Innerdyn were offered
were they were needed, not where they were not, and kept the
total price of the set more affordable than all hollow iron
set designs.
top of page
-
First set of metal woods and irons with a face insert
1992 - Dynacraft Coalition Woods and Irons
In the early 1990s, the USGA modified their rules to allow
face inserts made from a different material than the body
of the head to become a part of the design of any clubhead
made from metal. To do this required clubhead designers and
their production foundries to learn all new manufacturing
procedures. The Coalition woods and irons not only became
the first full set of woods and irons with a separate striking
insert installed in the faces. The design also brought
about an improvement in clubhead weight distribution for performance
improvement as well. BY removing a portion of the steel in
the face and replacing it with a very light but strong polymer,
more weight became available to be used in the enhancement
of the clubhead’s perimeter weighting and CG location.
By assisting the production foundry in the development of
manufacturing methods and machinery to allow the Coalition
to be made, the foundry hired Tom as a consultant in materials
and manufacturing technology, a relationship which still exists
between the two parties today.
top of page
-
First one-piece investment cast undercut cavity ironhead
1994 - Golfsmith** RMC270 Irons
Ironheads with an undercut back cavity became a popular offering
of many companies in the late 1990s and early 2000s. The first
such ironhead design which attempted to “scoop out”
mass from the back and position more weight farther behind
the face to move the CG farther back from the shaft for a
higher trajectory was the RMC270, which was designed by Tom
approximately 5-6 years before undercut irons became a popular
style of design with other companies in the golf equipment
industry.
top of page
-
First wooden driver head >250cc in volume/size
1994 - Golfsmith Long Jon Laminated Maple + Graphite Insert
Driver
In the early to mid-1990s, the trend toward making larger
driver heads had begun. Yet, the skills of the foundries and
the use of lighter and stronger metals was not quite up to
the task of keeping up with the market’s demand for
even larger head shapes. While metal woodheads dominated in
sales popularity, in the early 1990s there was still a worthwhile
demand for wooden woodheads. Prior to the Long Jon, the largest
wooden driver head was 200cc in volume. By using the stronger
laminated maple for the woodhead, performing R&D to determine
the maximum possible size of a mass-reduction cavity inside
the wooden head, and using very light polymer in the face
and striking areas of the head to reduce mass, the Long Jon
was able to achieve a significantly larger head size at just
over 250cc in volume.
top of page
-
First metal wood manufactured with no internal foam
filling
1994 - Golfsmith Solid Tone Stainless Steel Driver
Prior to 1994, all investment cast stainless steel drivers
were manufactured with their internal cavity filled with urethane
foam. This had been done since the beginning of stainless
wood manufacture in the late 1970s to dampen the sound of
impact from the metal woods, so that golfers making the switch
from wooden heads to metal would not be greeted with such
a dramatic change in the sound of hitting the ball. On the
average size stainless steel driver, the weight of the urethane
foam used to fill the internal cavity would range from 20-30
grams. Thus the weight of the foam had to be considered in
the design of the metal wood, which in turn limited the weight
distribution that could be incorporated in the design of the
head. In 1994, Tom decided to depart completely from
tradition by designing a stainless wood with no internal foam,
so that the weight normally taken up by the foam could be
used to increase the size and improve the off-center hit performance
of the driver. As a result, the Solid Tone certainly had that
– a very different and much higher pitched sound at
impact which came from the elimination of the internal foam.
Within 2 years, the rest of the golf industry followed suit
and today, no metal wood in the golf industry is made with
internal foam.
top of page
-
First set of ironheads with all CNC machined faces
1995 - Golfsmith CNC5000 Irons
In the middle-1990s virtually all ironheads were manufactured
by investment casting. While a very accurate process for repeating
specifications and shapes in large production, the faces of
investment cast irons at this time were never perfectly flat.
In addition, in the middle 1990s the dispute between V- or
U-shaped grooves, and which was better for generating more
backspin was raging in the golf equipment industry. The CNC5000
ironheads were investment cast after which, each face was
precision computer machined to virtually perfect flatness.
In addition, a milling cutter pattern was chosen which created
a texture on the entire face that increased the friction between
the face and the ball in an effort to enhance the spin on
the ball. However, perhaps the most significant part
of the manufacture of the CNC5000 was that the irons still
had consistent USGA legal score lines – given the nature
of face flatness variations from the investment casting process,
machining the face after casting could have created wide variations
in the width and depth of the lines on the face. Thus to even
manufacture the CNC5000 irons, the casting process had to
be improved to make a very flat face right out of casting
so that when the faces were machined, the scorelines were
still consistent and USGA legal.
top of page
-
First graphite driver with heel weighting for slice
correction
1995 - Golfsmith AccuCore Graphite Driver
The concept for heel weighting of clubheads and how such weight
distribution could assist golfers with a tendency to push
or slice the ball originally was revealed in Cochran and Stobbs’
milestone book, The Search for the Perfect Swing.
In addition, Tom Wishon had seen and helped perfect the making
of an early heel weighted wooden driver that had been developed
by the late Elmore Just’s Louisville Golf Company in
1991-2. But the problem with a heel-weighted wooden head was
that the relatively high density of the laminated maple or
persimmon did not allow more than 10-15 grams to be positioned
in the heel, which was minimal in its ability to assist with
slice correction. By using graphite for the head body material,
the AccuCore graphite driver was able to be designed larger
in size and allow the use of 35 grams of weight to create
a driver head which delivered a visible push/slice improvement
for golfers.
top of page
-
First graphite + metal hollow cavity driver head
1995 - Golfsmith Power Link Driver
Golfers may look at the 2004 Fusion model driver and believe
its metal + graphite hollow body design was originated by
Callaway Golf Company. However, the first such metal + graphite
hollow body woodhead design was commercially developed by
Tom Wishon in 1995. Tom had always been intrigued by the possibility
of combining two materials of different density in the same
clubhead for the purpose of improving weight distribution
and CG location. The Power Link was another example of a pioneering
design in both weight distribution and in new manufacturing
engineering to enable such a design to be made. The Power
Link’s investment cast stainless steel face and sole
piece was placed into a compression mold with a special inert
core so that graphite could be molded to the steel face/sole
piece to create the hollow driver head with a very high portion
of the head’s total weight positioned in the sole and
face to keep the CG low and more forward. Of particular difficulty
in the design was having to master the precision of the cast
stainless part to fit in the compression mold the same exact
way every time, and to engineer the fit and durability of
the graphite to the edges of the steel all around the face
and sole edges.
top of page
-
First metal wood with adjustable hosel sleeve for
customizing the face angle and lie
1995 - Golfsmith AHT metal woods
While golfers are now familiar with the plastic hosel insert
in PING brand woods to allow golfers to choose a lie and face
angle that best fits their style of play, the first metal
woods to offer this concept for customizing were the AHT woods
designed by Tom Wishon in 1995. The neck of the AHT woods
was designed to accept a precision machined aluminum sleeve
into which the shaft was inserted for assembly. The
sleeve was machined so that it could be rotated in the neck
of the woods to allow a series of different lie and face angle
orientations when the shaft was installed.
top of page
-
First driver family designed with specifications
matched to different golfer swing speeds
1995 - Golfsmith Designated Drivers
While golf publications just began to write about the importance
of higher loft for greater carry distance in 2003, in the
mid-1990s, Tom began to educate clubmakers on the importance
of increasing loft on the driver as a way to increase distance
for golfers with slower clubhead speed. Prior to this information,
clubmakers and golfers had always assumed that the lower the
loft, the greater the distance generated by the driver. The
Designated Driver series consisted of 5 different stainless
steel driver heads, each made with a different loft, face
height and face angle that was matched to 10mph increments
of golfer swing speed from <70mph up to >100mph.
top of page
-
First titanium metal wood introduced in the USA
1994 - Golfsmith Titanium 230 Driver
The first Titanium alloy metal woods in the world were developed
and manufactured by Japanese foundries, and were introduced
by Japanese clubmaking companies for sale only in Japan. US
companies were hesitant to embrace the potential for Titanium
in driver design because of the much higher cost of the heads
and because of the fact that virtually none of the experienced
woodhead making foundries in Taiwan had the capability of
producing woodheads made from Titanium alloys. Realizing the
potential of Titanium’s ideal strength to elasticity
characteristics for increasing driver performance, and understanding
the learning curve to manufacture Ti heads being faced by
the Taiwan foundries, Tom researched and began to develop
a working relationship with engineers from the Metal Park
foundry, located outside Moscow in Russia. Metal Park had
years of experience in casting Titanium, but had no experience
in the manufacture of golf clubheads. With Metal Park providing
the Titanium know-how, Tom advised and taught the Russian
engineers about the technical requirements of woodhead production
tooling – the result was not only the first Titanium
woodheads ever introduced in the US, but also the first clubheads
of any design or material that were produced by a Russian
manufacturer. Other golf companies in the US to subsequently
work with Metal Park in Russia to manufacture Ti woodheads
included Taylor Made.
top of page
-
First putter head with polymer backed face
1995 - Golfsmith Insulator Putter
Most people who design wood and ironheads do not design putter
heads, and vice versa. Some of the most well-known putter
designers such as John Reuter (Bulls-Eye), Otey Chrisman,
Scotty Cameron, and Bobby Grace restrict their design talents
only to putters. The Insulator model putter was created by
Tom in an effort to design a putter head with soft feel for
hard, 2-piece ball construction types but with a metal striking
face for less friction between the ball and the putter face.
Granted, while this was a relatively ugly head shape for which
Tom would admit deserving a “thumbs down” in response,
the technology for reducing friction between the face and
the ball while still delivering a soft impact feel was very
sound.
top of page
-
First iron set with progressive topline thickness
for vertical center of gravity change
1996 - Golfsmith XTR II Plus Irons
In a design shape and style that Tom later admitted was a
bit on the weird side, and thus could have been inspired by
the metallic multi-faceted comic book anti-hero to Superman
known as “Bizarro”, the XTR-II ironhead set represented
a design in which the topline width was kept thin on the long
irons (3.5mm on the #1-iron) and then allowed to widen progressively
through the set (12mm on the wedges). Through this design
feature, it was possible to keep more of the head mass lower
for a lower CG in the long irons, while progressively moving
the CG higher to offset hitting the ball too high as loft
increased through to the short irons and wedges. Thus even
modern designs such as the Cleveland Micro-Cavity irons, in
which weight is removed from the topline to enhance the CG
location, stand as a concept pioneered initially in a Tom
Wishon design.
top of page
-
First stainless steel driver head to exceed 225cc
volume
1996 - Golfsmith SS-235 Driver
When Titanium woodheads were introduced in the US in 1994,
(See design #14) the lower density of Titanium opened the
door for designers to meet the public’s increasing demand
for ever-larger driver head shapes. However, in the mid-1990s,
Titanium drivers were significantly more expensive than what
the majority of golfers in the US were yet willing to pay.
Thus there was a also a demand for larger stainless steel
drivers. The SS-235 was a 235cc driver head investment cast
from 17-4 stainless steel which employed changes in the shell
formation of the steel casting process followed by a different
heat treatment to allow the SS-235 to have a thinner wall
construction which was still strong enough to withstand normal
impact. Thus the increase in volume size was accomplished
which pushed the envelope in stainless steel driver head manufacture
to a size not yet seen before in the golf industry.
top of page
-
First heel weighted metal wood driver for slice correction
1996 - Golfsmith AccuCore Driver
(See design #10 for preliminary information)
The AccuCore Graphite driver represented a way to greatly
increase the amount of heel weighting for slice correction
by using a low density graphite composite for the head body
material. However, by 1996 the market demand for graphite
body woodheads was in decline. In an effort to satisfy the
market’s greater demand for metal woodheads and still
offer a significant level of slice correction, Tom turned
to high strength 7005-T6 treated aluminum as the material
of choice for the AccuCore metal driver body. With aluminum
being very low in density and comprising the entire body construction,
it was still possible to create a large 240cc woodhead and
still increase the mass of the slice correction (draw-bias)
heel weight plug to 50 grams. Thus the AccuCore metal wood
driver satisfied the market demand for a metal wood, and at
the same time was able to deliver a higher level of push/slice
correction than its forerunner.
top of page
-
First metal wood with titanium wrap-around face construction
1997 - Golfsmith BlackHawk Driver
Even before Tom began to assign sophisticated face modeling
computer software to investigate the potential performance
of a metal wood face design, he was aware that the strength
to modulus ratio of Titanium made a better face material for
increasing ball velocity. In addition, Tom realized that the
Ti face’s spring face capability would be enhanced by
increasing the surface area of the Ti face that would be unsupported
or untouched by welding. By forging the 6/4 titanium face
in a wrap-around construction and then casting the high strength
7005-T6 aluminum material of the body of the Black Hawk Driver
around the ‘cupped’ edges of the Ti face, the
deflection (spring face) capability of the face for its designed
size was able to be maximized. The same wrap-around, or what
is also called ‘cup-face’ Ti face construction
as employed by Callaway Golf in their Titanium woodheads,
did not come about until 2-3 years later.
top of page
-
First metal wood with stainless body + aluminum hosel
1997 - Golfsmith Bi-Metallic woods
A designer can look at the weight contained in the hosel of
the clubhead in two ways – it is mass that can be used
to assist in slice correction by helping to move the CG closer
to the shaft, or it can be mass that can be eliminated or
reduced and thus re-distributed in the head to improve perimeter
weighting or vertical CG location. Following the latter design
technology, the Bi-Metallic woods were a set in which Tom
designed the body of the heads from 17-4 stainless steel and
was able to increase weight distribution inside the body of
the head by designing the hosel as a separate part made from
high strength 7075-T6 aluminum. In addition, because the hosel
was made from aluminum, vibration from the head up to the
golfer’s hands was also able to be reduced.
top of page
-
First metal woodhead to exceed 350cc volume
1997 - Golfsmith Long Jon jumbo metal driver
Today, a 350cc metal wood Driver is a common design - 6 years
ago it was virtually unthinkable to conceive of a Driver head
of that size because Titanium woodhead construction and forming
technology had just advanced to the point of being able to
make a 300cc size Driver that would withstand the normal wear
and tear of play. Again turning to high strength aluminum
alloys for the solution, the Long Jon metal wood Driver was
totally forged from aircraft grade 7005-T6 aluminum to be
able to deliver the strength required to accommodate a high
performance Driver of 350cc size. At the time, the Long Jon
was nearly 50cc larger than any metal Driver yet made.
top of page
-
First metal wood with aluminum body joined to stainless
steel sole for ultra-low CG
1997 - Golfsmith Super Track Woods
The very playable concept of a super heavy sole attached to
a high loft fairway woodhead first became commercially successful
in the 1970s with the popularity of clubs like the Stan Thompson
Ginty and the Cobra Baffler. However, no company or designer
had ever converted the heavy sole design concept to a metal
wood to meet the market’s universal demand for a heavy
sole metal wood. Never before had the concept been accomplished
on a driver to potentially increase the launch angle. The
reason was threefold – 1) Drivers being so much larger
than fairway woods did not allow significant amounts of additional
mass to be positioned on the sole, 2) nearly 100% of
the high-end metal fairway wood sales were in stainless steel.
With steel being very high in density, this did not allow
much mass to be located in the sole to lower the CG. 3) Titanium,
which with its low density would allow a heavier mass to be
attached to the sole, was in 1997 still limited chiefly to
driver sales because of its much higher cost – i.e.
golfers would spend more for a single Driver but would not
yet spend the same amount for a titanium fairway wood.
Thus, the Super Track became the first full set of metal woods
with a truly heavy sole metal Driver and high lofted trouble
wood. Rather than use screws to attach the stainless
steel railed sole piece to the very light aluminum top shell
which had less “eye appeal” and could potentially
come loose with use, Tom chose to design the Super Track by
inserting the investment cast steel sole piece into the forging
dies for the 7005-T6 aluminum so the body could be press fit
together with the heavy sole. The result was a series of metal
woods from driver to fairway trouble woods that had a very
low CG and were extremely easy for golfers to hit.
top of page
-
First titanium iron with bi-metal construction
introduced in the USA
1997 - Golfsmith MWD1000 Irons
Titanium irons had a short life in the golf industry, chiefly
because a full set cost nearly $2000, second because the first
sets introduced by Tommy Armour Golf were far larger in blade
size than what golfers were comfortable with playing. Titanium
when formed into a hollow body, thin face woodhead design
performs well because its high strength to modulus ratio allows
for a faster ball velocity off the face. However, when Titanium
was formed into a solid body construction for an iron, the
spring face capability is gone and the low density of the
Ti requires the head to be extremely large to achieve normal
iron headweights. The MWD-1000 irons recognized that
the potential for Titanium in an iron design could only be
realized by designing the head close to a normal ironhead
size, and then employing the use of heavy density weights
to be attached to the head to reach normal headweights, and
to improve the perimeter weighting and CG requirements of
a good game improvement ironhead design. Thus the MWD-1000
irons became the first Ti ironhead to utilize a second metal
(brass) in the design to allow the creation of a more normal
size head with greater perimeter weighting at the same time.
top of page
-
First clubheads designed with weight addition cavity
at the base of the hosel
All new Golfsmith, Penick clubhead models starting in 1997
Clubhead models designed for assembly with any shaft or grip
are easier for clubmakers to assemble to the desired swingweight
if there is a way to add weight to the clubhead. Prior to
1997, all clubheads that were made with a weight addition
capability utilized an unsightly screw to allow access to
the port for adding lead powder. In 1997, Tom Wishon
designed the “weight bore” which was located at
the bottom of the shafting bore in the neck of the clubhead
to allow clubmakers to add a series of weight plugs of different
mass to enable them to achieve desired swingweights with their
assembled clubs. The weights could be epoxied into the
weight bore before the shaft was installed. Thus not only
did the shaft lock the weight in place, but the weight addition
was invisible and did not detract from the appearance of the
clubhead.
top of page
-
First iron with titanium face insert + high density
metal weighting bar for 3-Metal construction
1998 - Golfsmith BlackHawk Irons
The design of the BlackHawk irons was originally intended
to be a Titanium face design that would first introduce a
slight spring face nature into an iron, and which also used
the Ti face and brass back bar to change weight distribution
more dramatically in an iron than possible with a homogenous
metal construction. By using Titanium for the face, an additional
25-30 grams of mass could be re-distributed into areas of
the head to improve perimeter weighting and CG location. Additionally,
by inserting a brass back bar behind the face, the CG was
also pulled slightly back from the face, thus slightly enhancing
the trajectory of shots hit with these irons. In addition
the BlackHawk became the first ironhead designed with three
different metals on the same head.
top of page
-
First boron carbide metal matrix investment cast
clubhead
1998 – Golfsmith Cermet 2000 Driver
Aluminum metal matrix composite (MMC) materials have to be
thought of as almost being ‘aluminum on steroids’.
On its own, the highest strength aluminum alloys can rarely
exceed 100,000 psi in strength (6/4 Ti and 17-4 stainless
steel are 140,000 psi, 10-2-3 Beta Ti is 185,000 psi and Carpenter
455 steel is 250,000 psi to contrast). However, by adding
a ceramic material the strength of the resulting MMC can be
significantly increased in strength, to the point that some
MMC’s will approach and even exceed the strength of
some stainless steel alloys. As a material for potential use
in clubhead manufacture, MMCs held the potential for very
high strength to weight ratio so a large head size can be
designed with additional weight available to be added to specific
areas of the head to greatly enhance perimeter weighting.
In the mid-1990s a company named Langert Golf had introduced
a small size driver head made from Aluminum ‘alloyed’
with a ceramic called Silicon Carbide (SiC). The head was
produced through a very expensive die casting procedure that
was required to keep the distribution of the SiC consistent
through the aluminum and thus achieve consistent strength
equally in all areas of the head. SiC MMCs are known to be
very brittle. The Cermet 2000 was innovative because it no
MMC had yet been produced by investment casting. In addition,
it incorporated the use of Boron Carbide (B4C) ceramic particles.
Through investment casting, the tooling costs and the per
head cost could be greatly reduced, while the use of B4C increased
the MMC strength while making the MMC less brittle. This allowed
the Cermet 2000 to be made in a larger head size and in different
models of loft for a price that was far less expensive than
a Titanium driver head. Later the Cermet heads originated
by Tom Wishon expanded their performance potential with the
addition of bi-material weighting to further improve on their
perimeter weighting capability.
top of page
-
First Driver with maraging steel alloy face to exceed
300cc in volume
1998 - Golfsmith Super Sonic Boom Driver
Maraging steel is a classification given to certain alloys
of steel which possess extremely high strength, in the range
of 300,000 psi, or more than twice that of common metal woodhead
stainless steel alloys such as 15-5 and 17-4. In the late
1990s, maraging steel had only been used as the face plate
attached to a common stainless steel body and never designed
to be larger than 240-250cc in size. By attaching the maraging
face to a 300cc forged high strength aluminum body, the Super
Sonic Boom Driver not only became the largest steel face Driver
in the golf industry, but the maraging steel face eliminated
the less popular “thud” sound of an all aluminum
woodhead. The result was a high performance ultra-thin face
construction that not only enhanced the spring face capability
but rendered a more favorable sound at impact.
top of page
-
First beta grade titanium alloy driver introduced
in the USA
1998 - Golfsmith Beta Titanium 255LT Driver
Alloys of Beta Titanium represented a definite increase in
the strength to modulus ratio for titanium woodheads so that
drivers could be made larger in size, and made with a higher
C.O.R. than what was possible using the 6/4 Titanium alloy
that had been so predominant in titanium driver design up
to this time. While the US market of golfers had become accustomed
to the higher price of a 6/4 Titanium alloy driver by this
time, the higher raw material cost of the more sophisticated
Beta grade titanium alloys would raise driver prices even
higher. Therefore, in the late 1990s, all of the US
golf companies were hesitant about switching from 6/4 titanium
to a beta grade titanium for their driver designs. Because
Tom was starting to rely on computer modeling at this time
to predict the performance of a driver face design, he knew
the potential for both increasing head size and improving
the COR of the driver face design that the better beta grade
titanium alloys offered. Thus, in 1998 the model 255LT beta
titanium driver was not only a larger size driver than what
had been offered before, but also increased the COR over what
had been done before, and became the first driver made from
a beta titanium alloy commercially offered in the US.
top of page
-
First iron manufactured with aluminum alloy body
1998 - Golfsmith TG System Irons
In ironhead design, Tom knew from his previous experience
with designing the titanium + brass MWD1000 irons that iron
performance was all about being able to re-position weight
in specific areas of the head to improve off-center hit forgiveness
and improve the CG location to improve the launch angle of
the ball off the irons. To gain more mass to move to
desired areas of the iron required that the body of the iron
be made from the lightest material possible that was still
able to withstand the force of impact. Because irons
are subjected to far less impact stress than woods, Tom decided
to turn to a high grade aluminum alloy to construct the body
of the ironhead. Because aluminum has a density less than
half that of titanium and 70% lower than steel, this allowed
the re-positioning of a tremendous amount of the total weight
of an ironhead. The TG System irons were thus designed with
a large tungsten weight placed in the sole of each ironhead
to greatly lower the CG, with two additional heel and toe
located weights to improve the moment of inertia of the head
to make off center hits more forgiving. Thus the TG
System irons became the first aluminum body iron ever designed
and offered a greater amount of weight distribution enhancement
than any iron yet made.
top of page
-
First iron with multiple face thickness variations
for CG and weight distribution control
1998 - Golfsmith Jetstream 2 Irons
In 1998, Tom had discovered that moving the CG slightly off
the center of the face scoreline area and a little more toward
the shaft would allow the golfer more time to rotate the club
back to square on the downswing and thus reduce the chance
of pushing or fading the ball. It was also recognized by most
designers that a lower CG was preferred for average to less
skilled players. Prior to this time, investment cast stainless
steel irons were always made with a uniform face thickness
of 3mm so the CG position had to be controlled by the height
of the blade or the width of the sole. The Jetstream 2 irons
were designed with different thicknesses over different areas
of the face – the upper toe area was reduced to 2mm
and the lower toe area to 2.5mm to keep weight from being
high on the head and too far from the shaft. The bottom areas
of the face were increased to 4mm thickness to help move the
CG lower in the head. Thus the original height of the blade
and sole width could be retained while still being able to
manipulate the position of the CG in the head. This design
required very precise production dies to be made to ensure
the accuracy of the face thickness design and thus be able
to move the CG to the desired position lower on the head and
a little closer to the shaft to offer golfers more control
and accuracy.
top of page
-
First set of metal woods matching stainless steel
fairway woods with a titanium driver
1999 - Snake Eyes CMF Metal Woods
Today, virtually all fairway woods made to match with a titanium
driver are designed from steel. In the late 1990s that was
not the case as all companies chose to make titanium fairway
woods to match their Ti drivers because they were concerned
a change in metal in the set would bring a change in performance
that would not match. Because Tom’s wood designs had
been incorporating computer modeling of the face since 1997,
he knew that there were ways to engineer the face design of
steel woods so that they could offer a very close feel and
ball velocity performance that would match up well with Titanium.
The incentive to do this came from the fact that titanium
fairway wood sales were far lower than titanium driver sales.
Market studies showed that golfers were more than willing
to pay the higher cost for a titanium driver because it represented
a single club that was of great importance in playing the
game. However, golfers shied away from paying a high price
for matching titanium fairway woods because the total cost
of a set of 3 or 4 woods became too high for their comfort
level. Tom recognized this market trend himself and
stepped out to computer model the design the Snake Eyes CMF
fairway woods from steel with a thinner face than had been
done before on a fairway wood. The result was a full set of
Titanium driver with steel fairway woods that matched well
in performance and offered the golfer a high performance alternative
for a full set of matched woods that was lower in price.
Thus Tom pioneered a trend in wood set design with the Snake
Eyes CMF woods that is now followed by virtually all equipment
companies.
top of page
-
First Metal Wood to match face thickness to different
golfer specific swing speed ranges
1999 - Snake Eyes Elasteel driver and 3 wood
From further computer modeling studies of wood face design,
Tom noted that the maximum ball speed came when the face was
flexed inward to its maximum point. At the same time,
his computer modeling work revealed that the amount the face
could flex inward was proportional to the clubhead speed of
the golfer. That meant golfers with slower swing speeds
were buying titanium drivers with faces designed to flex fully
only for the highest swing speeds of golfers, and thus were
not getting the maximum ball velocity from their purchase.
Tom designed each of the three Snake Eyes Elasteel drivers
and 3-woods with a different face thickness that was computer
modeled to achieve its maximum face deflection for a specific
and different range of golfer swing speeds. Thus the golfer
with a 75-90mph swing speed used a driver with a 2.25mm thickness
face, a golfer with a 90-105mph swing used a 2.6mm face, and
golfers with a >105mph swing speed used the Elasteel driver
with a 2.9mm thickness face – and all three ranges of
swing speed players thus were able to gain the same amount
of face deflection and performance increase. However,
such a design concept required a heavy communication campaign
to prevent high swing speed golfers from using the Elasteel
driver and 3-wood designed only for the lower swing speed
force! Fortunately, people listened as only four Elasteel
drivers were returned with broken faces from being used by
a player with a higher swing speed than what the head was
designed to withstand!
top of page
-
First metal wood with wrap-around face construction
forged from high strength steel
2000 - Golfsmith TI Steel 465
Prior to 2000, all woodheads using a high strength steel alloy
for the face had been made by either press-fitting the face
piece into the face surface, or welding the face piece on
the very edges of the face of the wood. Such attachment methods
of the face to the body of the head reduced the area of the
face that was able to be flexed inward and with it, reduced
the potential for a high strength steel face to offer the
same ball velocity capable from a beta titanium face. During
this time, Tom Wishon had been working with a number of sophisticated
high strength steel alloy manufacturers and performing computer
face modeling of their various alloys that possessed strength
properties in the range of 250,000 – 300,000 psi. With
such ultra-high strength alloys, he had determined it was
possible to create steel face drivers that could offer the
same high C.O.R. capability as any of the beta titanium alloys.
However, to do that required that no welding touch the back
of the hitting face. Hence, by creating face forging
dies that would wrap the face piece around to allow the welding
attachment to be on the top, sole and sides of the body of
the head for the first time in a driver design, welding was
kept off the back of the face and the high strength steel
face construction was able to perform to its maximum spring
face capability.
top of page
-
First iron and wood set with progressively moving
tungsten weighting for specific flight performance
2000 - Lynx Black Cat MTW Woods and Irons; Harvey Penick Plus
Irons; Golfsmith Sterling Irons
At this time, some equipment companies were beginning to use
the very high density of tungsten to move the CG to be lower
on the clubhead for the purpose of increasing launch angle
of the ball from the clubhead. However, Tom recognized
that there was no need to lower the CG on high lofted fairway
woods or the higher loft irons in a set, because the much
greater loft angles of these heads generated a high enough
trajectory already. To continue to put tungsten low
on the head for all heads in the set meant the high lofted
clubheads would hit the ball too high and potentially reduce
distance. Thus in the above three different branded
set designs, Tom restricted the use of the tungsten to only
the heads in the set in which the lowering of the CG would
be advantageous to the launch angle of the shot. In
addition, the tungsten was placed more toward the heel on
the long irons to also shift the CG closer to the shaft, to
thus make these longer length clubs easier for the golfer
to rotate back to square on the downswing. Thus for
the first time in the golf industry, each ironhead in these
sets utilized its tungsten weighting for a specific function
unique to the loft and length of the club. In the Lynx
Black Cat woods, the tungsten sole weight piece was placed
closer farther from the face in the driver to enhance the
launch angle from the lowest lofted woodhead, but progressively
moved closer to the face for the matching #3, 5 and 7-woodheads
to prevent hitting the ball too high as loft increased through
the wood set.
top of page
-
First utility driving iron with heel located tungsten
weighting
2000 - Golfsmith XPC3 Driving Iron
By 2000, companies were recognizing that conventional low
loft iron clubs were too hard for most golfers to hit solid
and generate a high enough trajectory to maximize their distance.
Alternative hybrid long ironheads began to appear which all
were designed to be more broad from face to back than a conventional
ironhead of the same loft. This was done to move the CG farther
back from the face as a further method for increasing the
launch angle for the same low lofts. The first such
hybrid driving irons were popular with a number of players
on the professional tours because they were easier to generate
a high, soft landing trajectory for long approach shots into
greens. However, such low loft and longer length driving irons
were still difficult for average golfers to overcome a slice
or push, so to counteract this tendency, Tom designed the
XPC3 driving irons with tungsten weight on the bottom of the
sole, but moved into the heel side of the sole, so that the
CG could be kept low, but also shifted toward the shaft to
allow golfers to rotate the face back to square much easier,
and in the result reduce the tendency to push or slice the
ball.
top of page
-
First USGA C.O.R. non-conforming driver with steel
alloy face construction
2000 - Snake Eyes AerMet CMF Drivers
In 1999, the limit on the C.O.R. of a clubhead was a rule
of the game that was only in effect in the US and Mexico,
the only two countries who follow the Rules of Golf of the
United States Golf Association. As a result, golf companies
with the capability of designing high C.O.R. driver heads
would create two versions, one with a C.O.R. of less than
0.830 for use under USGA rules, and one with a higher C.O.R.
for use in all other countries legislated by the Royal &
Ancient of St. Andrews. Because the USGA wanted to keep
track of all “non-conforming” high C.O.R. drivers,
the rulemaking body published a listing of all of the non-conforming
drivers with a C.O.R. in excess of their 0.830 limit.
Until the design of the Snake Eyes AerMet CMF drivers, every
driver on the USGA’s non-conforming list was a titanium
alloy driver, because no golf companies had developed the
ability to manufacture a steel driver with a C.O.R. over the
USGA’s limit. Tom Wishon thus became the first
designer in the golf industry to create a steel face driver
with a C.O.R. higher than 0.830. This achievement came about
because of his knowledge of high strength steel alloys and
the ability to computer model the performance of such alloys.
(The C.O.R. of the Snake Eyes AerMet CMF drivers was 0.854)
top of page
-
First Thin Face Forged Steel Set of Irons
2001 - Snake Eyes Fire Forged Irons
Because of the vast experience of computer modeling thin face
drivers that could perform with a high C.O.R., Tom turned
his attention in 2000 to trying to determine if a thin face
design could improve performance in a set of irons. This was
a much more difficult project because the amount a face can
deflect inward and thus deliver a higher ball velocity, is
completely dependent on the loft angle of the face. The greater
the loft, the less deflection force is applied by impact with
the ball, and the less the opportunity for an improvement
in ball velocity. Thus with irons ranging in loft from 20
to over 50 degrees, Tom knew that he was going to be trying
to “squeeze blood from a turnip”, so to speak.
By working with a foundry which had the capability to custom
mix steel alloys to achieve different mechanical properties
in the final metal, a brand new high strength steel alloy
was created which possessed more elasticity than other steels
previously used in clubhead design. This alloy became the
material of choice to forge the 2.1mm thin steel faces for
each of the heads in the Snake Eyes Fire Forged irons. Because
Tom’s face modeling capability was restricted at the
time to uniform thickness face design, the Fire Forged irons
were not a variable thickness face, nor did the face thicknesses
change from head to head in the set of irons. (See #43)
Testing with the irons showed a slight increase in ball speed
with the #3 – 6 ironheads as a result of creating the
first truly thin face iron, along with a definite change in
the feel of impact due to the slight increase in face deflection.
top of page
-
First Putter head with vertical CG positioned at
same height as the CG of the golf ball
2001 - Snake Eyes Straight In Putters
Back in the 1970s, the former PGA Golf Company introduced
a putter which took the appearance of a flanged sole putter
head turned upside down so that the protrusion of the flange
stuck out from the top of the putter head. The model was designed
to move more mass high on the putter head in an effort to
induce less backspin and more forward roll on the putt. However,
this design did not actually move the CG of the putter head
up that far because its face height was still made to be in
the conventional putter head range of 24mm. The family
of Snake Eyes Straight-In putters were able to achieve a CG
position precisely level with the CG of the golf ball by designing
the heads with a much taller face height. The heads were designed
from soft aluminum in the center of the head and face, and
with tungsten heel and toe sections to also greatly increase
the MOI and off-center putt performance of the models. By
carefully engineering the weight distribution with the putter
head dimensions, thus the Snake Eyes Straight-In putters became
the first putter head design to deliver the CG position of
the head directly in line with the CG of the ball to more
effectively increase the potential for the ball to begin rolling
with overspin sooner after impact.
top of page
-
First putter head with ultra-low friction, ultra-thin
face insert to reduce putt side-spin
2002 - Golfsmith Friction Free Putter
2003 - Wishon
Golf Smoooth Series Putters
At a time when the most popular putter design concepts were
to either use a soft polymer material as the striking face
of the putter or CNC machine the face flat with swirled machining
marks, the Friction Free and Smoooth Series putters made a
complete departure by employing a very thin, highly polished
low-friction high-strength steel face insert to greatly reduce
the friction between the face and the ball. The softer the
striking face, and the more rough the surface condition of
the face, the more the ball will be “grabbed”
at impact and potentially pulled or pushed more off-line.
No golfer is able to execute the putting stroke perfectly
every time. Striking across the ball from an ‘outside-in’
or inside-out’ stroke is a common putting mistake among
all golfers. By using a very thin high-strength steel face
insert, a soft feel of ball contact could be retained in the
Friction Free and Smoooth Series putters. And by using a high
strength steel alloy, the face insert could be highly polished
AND nickel chrome plated to greatly reduce friction between
the face and the ball. The result was that on putts hit with
a slight push or pull stroke, the ball would not be “grabbed”
as much by the low friction face and thus offered a little
greater chance of sliding putts in the side of the hole that
would have no chance to fall if hit with a soft face insert
or CNC-machined face putter.
top of page
>> To view Tom's design "firsts" since starting
TWGT in 2002, please
click here. <<
*Dynacraft, Greyshadow, Genesis, Vari-Steel,
Innerdyn, Coalition, are all registered trademarks of Dynacraft
Golf Products, Inc.
**Golfsmith, RMC270, Long Jon, Solid-Tone,
CNC5000, AccuCore, Power Link, AHT, Designated Driver, Titanium
230, Insulator, SS-235, XTR-II, Accu-Core, BlackHawk, Bi-Metallic,
Super-Track, MWD1000, Cermet 2000, Super Sonic Boom, 255LT, TG
System, Jetstream, Snake Eyes, CMF, Elasteel, Ti-Steel, Lynx,
Black Cat, Sterling, XPC, Fire Forged, Straight-In, Friction Free
are all registered trademarks of Golfsmith International Company.
Harvey Penick and Penick are registered trademarks of the Harvey
Penick family licensed for use by Golfsmith International Company.
|
|